The International Court of Justice, or ICJ, is the United Nations’ principal judicial organ. It decides legal disputes that countries submit to it, applying international law, and it gives advisory opinions on legal questions sent to it by authorized UN bodies.
This guide follows a typical case through the court, step by step, and explains the limits that surprise many readers. For a comparison with the separate International Criminal Court, see the ICC and the ICJ explained.
What does the International Court of Justice do?
According to the court, it was established by the UN Charter in June 1945 and began its work in April 1946. It sits in the Peace Palace in The Hague, in the Netherlands, which makes it the only one of the UN’s six principal organs not based in New York. Its two official languages are English and French, and a Registry serves as its administrative organ.
The court does two distinct jobs:
- Contentious cases. A state brings a legal dispute against another state, and the court issues a judgment.
- Advisory proceedings. An authorized international organization asks a legal question, and the court issues an opinion.
Only states can be parties in contentious cases. Individuals, companies and cities cannot bring a case, and the court does not try people for crimes. How the court fits among the other UN bodies is covered in how the United Nations is organized.
Who sits on the bench?
The court has 15 judges, according to its own description. They are elected by the UN General Assembly and the Security Council, which vote at the same time but separately, and a candidate needs an absolute majority in both bodies. Terms last nine years, one third of the court is elected every three years, and judges may be re-elected. The court’s rules say it may not include more than one national of the same state.
Why can’t one country simply sue another?
The central idea is consent. A state cannot be pulled before the court merely because another state wants to sue it. The court describes three main routes by which a state’s consent can exist.
A special agreement
Two countries that already have a dispute can sign a treaty specifically sending it to the court. This is called a special agreement. It must identify the subject of the dispute and the parties, and it is notified to the court’s Registry. The court’s own page lists 19 cases that began this way.
A treaty clause
Many treaties include a compromissory clause, which is a provision saying that disputes over that treaty can go to the ICJ. A state that is party to such a treaty can file a unilateral written application against another party and should, as far as possible, cite the treaty provision it relies on. Article 37 of the court’s Statute also carries over certain older treaties that referred disputes to the League of Nations-era court.
A standing declaration
Under Article 36(2) of the Statute, states may declare that they recognize the court’s jurisdiction as compulsory in legal disputes. The declaration works only “in relation to any other State accepting the same obligation,” so it is reciprocal. The disputes covered are the interpretation of a treaty, any question of international law, the existence of a fact that would breach an international obligation, and the nature or extent of reparation for such a breach. Declarations may be unconditional, based on reciprocity or limited to a period, and they are deposited with the UN Secretary-General. The court’s page does not give a count of declarations, so readers should check its list of declarations for the current picture.
How does a case move from filing to judgment?
The court’s description of its procedure runs in stages.
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| Filing | Proceedings begin on the date the Registrar receives a special agreement or an application. An application must state the basis of jurisdiction, the facts and the grounds of the claim. |
| Preliminary objections | The respondent may challenge the court’s competence or the admissibility of the application. The court decides that question itself, and it can alter the normal sequence. |
| Provisional measures | If an applicant believes its rights are in immediate danger, it may ask for interim measures. |
| Written phase | Each side files pleadings setting out the facts and law it relies on. These are generally not made public until oral hearings open, unless the parties object. |
| Oral phase | Agents and counsel address the court at public hearings, with interpretation between English and French. |
| Deliberation | The judges deliberate in private. |
| Judgment | The decision is delivered at a public sitting. Any judge may attach an opinion. |
The court’s page gives no standard timetable for these stages, and readers should treat any single number of months or years with caution. Case length depends heavily on the dispute and on whether preliminary objections are raised.
A way to read case names
The court’s naming convention carries a small clue. In a case title, the parties’ names are separated by “v.” when the case began with a unilateral application and by an oblique stroke when it began with a special agreement. That tells you at a glance whether both sides agreed to come.
Are the court’s judgments binding?
Yes, for the parties. According to the court, a judgment is final, binding on the parties and not subject to appeal. It can be interpreted if its meaning is disputed, and it can be revised if a new fact is discovered. A UN member state undertakes to comply with the judgment in any case to which it is a party.
Enforcement is where the structure thins out. The court has no police force. If a party fails to perform, the other side may bring the matter to the Security Council, which can recommend or decide on measures. Because the council’s permanent members hold vetoes, that route is political rather than automatic, a point worth keeping in mind when reading about any compliance dispute. The council’s voting rules are explained in the United Nations article linked above.
What are advisory opinions, and do they bind anyone?
Advisory proceedings are separate from disputes between states. They are open only to public international organizations, “to them alone,” in the court’s words. The court says five UN organs, a number of specialized agencies and one related organization can request opinions, and it directs readers to a separate page for the names. Because the court’s own pages are not consistent about the exact count of specialized agencies, this article does not give one.
The process works roughly like this:
- The UN Secretary-General or the head of the requesting body files a written request with the Registrar. In urgent cases the court can speed things up.
- A few days after filing, the court identifies states and international organizations likely to provide information, usually the requesting body’s member states.
- Those listed may submit written statements, and the court may then allow written comments on them.
- Written statements are generally made public when oral proceedings begin, if the court holds any.
Advisory opinions are generally not binding. The requesting body decides what effect to give them, unless a treaty expressly says otherwise. The court’s page gives the Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations and the Headquarters Agreement with the United States as examples of instruments with such provisions. Even so, the court says opinions carry substantial legal weight and moral authority.
Common misunderstandings
“The ICJ can prosecute leaders.” It cannot. Individual criminal responsibility belongs to other courts, including the International Criminal Court, which is a separate institution.
“Any UN member can be sued.” Being a UN member does not by itself give the court jurisdiction over a particular dispute. A basis for consent must exist.
“A ruling ends the dispute.” A judgment settles the legal questions put to the court between the parties. Whether the underlying situation changes depends on compliance and politics.
“An advisory opinion is a verdict.” It is a legal answer to a question from an organization, not a ruling against a country, and it is generally not binding in itself.
Why does a court in The Hague matter on the Pacific border?
San Diego sits on an international border and a major Pacific port, so questions about treaties, crossings and maritime rules are part of local life. The ICJ does not handle those day-to-day matters, but it is one of the places where disputes over treaty obligations between states can be resolved peacefully, if the states involved agree to bring them. How treaties become binding for the United States is described in how treaties are ratified by the U.S. Senate. For the local side of the border, see how the San Ysidro crossing works.
Following a case without getting lost
The court publishes its pending cases, judgments, orders and press releases on its website. Three questions help when reading about any ICJ news: Is this a dispute between states or an advisory request? Is it a final judgment, a provisional measure or a procedural step? And what basis of jurisdiction did the parties rely on? Those answers usually reveal how far a decision can reach.
This article is general information explaining how an international institution works, not legal advice.
Sources: International Court of Justice



